WLD-D24-004 · Observed 2024-12-09
emergingFault-tolerant Quantum Breakthrough
Qualitative signpost review · no probability assigned
Bounded observation
Google Quantum AI demonstrated below-threshold surface-code memories on Willow: distance-5 and distance-7 codes with real-time decoding, with logical error suppressed as code distance increased. This satisfies a falling-logical-error signpost but not scalable manufacturing or repeatable useful-problem advantage.
Trigger threshold
Move to observed only when below-threshold logical qubits scale to a reproducible system that completes a defined useful problem with independently auditable advantage and an engineering path to manufacturing.
Counter-indicator
The experiment is a quantum-memory/error-correction milestone; it is not a cryptographically relevant or general fault-tolerant computer and does not demonstrate commercial fabrication yield.
Update criterion
Track replicated logical error per cycle, logical-qubit count, circuit depth, useful benchmark verification and manufacturing yield; remain emerging while only the first component is met.